Youtuber Matt Granger has printed an 18-minute Nikon 50mm shootout that pits the Nikkor Z 50mm f/1.8 in opposition to the 50mm f/1.2 and the 58mm f/0.95 Noct. As Granger says, each and every system wants a gigantic 50mm lens, so which of those is the reliable?
There are a ramification of factors to establish in solutions when pitting these three lenses in opposition to one any other. For one, no longer all of them are 50mm lenses: the Noct is a 58mm and whereas that’s no longer a immense distinction, it’s a long way price noting.
Additionally, and possibly extra clearly, the cost differences amongst these three lenses is a bit coarse. On the low stop, the 50mm f/1.8 is $500. A step up from that, the 50mm f/1.2 is $2,100. By hook or by crook, the 58mm f/0.95 Noct is $8,000. Additionally, that Noct doesn’t feature autofocus and is believed of by many to be extra of a showpiece optic than one that a photographer would in fact exhaust. Aloof, it’s available for the Nikon Z mount and as such it’s primary to behold the design it performs versus lenses which would possibly be extra doable.
Granger equipped PetaPixel with two models of image samples from all three lenses for your perusal. First is a extra oldschool portrait:
Below are 100% crops from each and every sample:
Below is a 2d image blueprint to study:
And any other time, below are 100% crops from each and every sample:
Must you might possibly possibly also be desirous to behold at these photos for your self, Granger has uploaded the RAW recordsdata right here.
“I went out desirous to devour the 58mm Noct,” Granger says. “I will be able to love unbelievable engineering and perfection despite the indisputable reality that it has tradeoffs of tag and size. However shooting these facet by facet, it in fact factual bolstered my thought that right here’s for this form of limited market and I’m no longer in that market, unfortunately.”
Unsurprisingly, Granger says the 58mm used to be no longer a sensible likelihood. On the diversified hand, the diversified two 50mm lenses have faith a lot extra to present to extra other folks. Granger states that he does think the f/1.2 model is more fit than the f/1.8, unsurprisingly, but doesn’t dart to this point as to divulge the f/1.8 isn’t a factual lens. Reckoning to your budget, either likelihood goes to doubtless satisfy your wants.
Based mostly totally on the samples he offers, what are your solutions?
We recommend you behold Granger’s total video, and for extra from him construct obvious you subscribe to his YouTube Channel.