An Extraordinarily-Enormous-Perspective Mirrorless Lens Shootout: Sigma 14-24mm vs Tamron …


Let’s speak referring to essentially the most transferring and hardest lens to grasp: the extremely vast perspective. Proper here is an outstanding lens that allows you to share weird views of just about any area by cramming a whole bunch of environment in a single physique. Should you might properly per likelihood even be out there out there for a kind of, apply on as I consider two of the most convenient in the marketplace.

By definition, the ultra-wide-perspective lenses are one factor else shorter than 24mm on a plump-body digicam and 15mm on an APS-C sized sensor.

Proper here is half favorable-attempting personally. The other half of that is that fisheye desires to be its rating class. I dangle in thoughts this one factor else beneath 12mm that’s the place you unquestionably provoke to attain horizon warping and that fishbowl warping turns into mighty further accepted.

So which lens would per likelihood maybe additionally restful you rating? You preserve a mirrorless digicam and likewise it’s most lifelike to attain in on this ultra-wide trek nonetheless what is the handiest?! Effectively learn on and I’ll reply that very question. I preserve narrowed it all the way down to the 2 handiest lenses that I’ve unquestionably define this class for mirrorless cameras. The Sigma 14-24mm f2.8 DG DN ART lens and the Tamron 17-28mm f/2.8 Di III RXD.

Iceland is the ultimate vast perspective lens playground. This play is a type of places that may offer you each alternative to discover the ingenious doable of an ultra-wide-perspective lens.

Let’s Shriek About These Two Lenses


  • Each lenses are designed for mirrorless cameras.
  • Each lenses are lower than $1,500.
  • Each lenses preserve a relentless f/2.8.
  • These two lenses signify the 2 types of people who’re making an attempt to amass an ultra-wide-perspective lenses.
  • Out of the entire lenses I examined on this class these are the best two I might comfortably suggest to any individual of any ability stage.

Let me deal with the elephant within the room. Brad, why not the Sony 12-24mm f/2.8 GM? To be completely truthful I don’t unquestionably like Sony lenses. I preserve rented only a few GM and others they every so often’ve by no map wowed me. Plus, that prepare is $3,000. I offered all 3 of the lenses I in the mean time raise for that similar cash.

3 lenses!

Fleshy Width

For the remainder of this comparability, I’m going to be utilizing best uncooked un-edited photos from each lens, with some scene comparisons on the head. Each shot grow to be thunder up on a tripod and the best commerce grow to be which lens grow to be mounted to the Sony a7R III.

For the aspect-by-aspect comparability, I’m utilizing a gross shot of my yard that has favorable straight traces to stage warp and tough little print the entire method to the edge of the physique. This alteration into shot in overcast skies for even lights that fades from glowing to darkish from high to bottom.

Sigma 14-24mm – $1,399. 14mm, f/11, 1/20s, ISO 160.
At plump width there’s fairly not warp within the strait traces of the timber. There’s an just about imperceptible stretching of on the very fringe of the physique which you’ll look beneath. The little print deeper within the physique, from the side highway attend, are a exiguous bit softer then the Tamron and the edge little print within the dwelling aren’t as successfully outlined because the Tamron.
Tamron 17-28mm – $899. 17mm, f/11, 1/20s, ISO 160.
Absolutely zoomed out this lens supplies massive heart readability with the slightest warping within the corners. The deeper little print are are mighty clearer everytime you happen to pixel look you might properly per likelihood even rating out the precise explicit individual bricks on the noxious of the dwelling within the attend left. Nonetheless this lens loses sharpness as you provoke to method the edges of the physique.

Deep little print:

Sigma 14-24mm
Tamron 17-28mm

Bottom 1/4 of the photographs:

Sigma 14-24mm
Tamron 17-28mm

Bottom 1/4 sharpness:

Sigma 14-24mm
Tamron 17-28mm

Edge sharpness bottom left nook:

Sigma 14-24mm
Tamron 17-28mm
Sigma 14-24mm
Tamron 17-28mm

The Sigma loses some prepare of the extra attend within the picture (rental) a few of this is ready to properly even be recovered in submit nonetheless it’s a good distance one factor to dangle in thoughts. Nonetheless, edge to edge, nook to nook it can render each pixel the entire method to the very fringe of the physique in focal stage.

The Tamron is sort of freakishly energetic within the heart of the physique nonetheless the extent of passion begins to descend off attractive quickly. Even attractive a good distance into the picture (the place the concrete spherical is) you might properly per likelihood look the leaves are initiating to lose sharpness and everytime you happen to attain it to the nook they’re silent ample that they will not be saved.


Sigma 14-24mm f/2.8 DG DN ART


  • Piquant the entire method to the edge.
  • On the spot focal stage.
  • Has a AF/MF change and and a focal stage lock button you might properly per likelihood program to defend out different points.
  • Almost no distortion.


  • $1399: that is within the prosumer rental to be particular nonetheless for any individual appropriate beginning it’s a good distance a arduous tablet to swallow for one lens.
  • Heavy: at 827 grams you might properly per likelihood unquestionably really feel this all-metal beast in your fetch and within the hand.
  • Should you’d take to disclose filters with this you might properly per likelihood even be going to keep up to take a enviornment of experience holder that may tag you an extra $200-$600 relying, and it’s a good distance one different massive merchandise to defend.

Tamron 17-28mm f/2.8 Di III RXD


  • $899
  • Deadly energetic within the heart.
  • LIGHT, it best weighs 484 grams. This lens with the 28-75 2.8 from Tamron barely weigh further than the Sigma on it’s rating.
  • Accent filters are dust low-cost and one filter works for all 3 of the lenses in Tamron’s mirrorless line up!


  • Loses sharpness attractive quickly towards the edge of the physique.
  • It zooms backwards – deepest choice nonetheless all lenses would per likelihood maybe additionally restful flip counter clockwise to zoom.
  • No AF/MF change – I don’t would like to fumble in menus after I ought to all the time quickly regulate the extent of passion manually.

Which one would per likelihood maybe additionally restful you take?

So it’s a good distance a more difficult question to answer to than I might per likelihood even preserve thought and I’ve I’m going to keep up to supply two solutions. I actually preserve the Sigma and it’s a good distance among the many lenses I really by no map depart dwelling. It’s all the time in my fetch heavy and cross as a result of it’s a good distance, I freaking esteem it.

1. Possess the Tamron. Significantly for truthful about all folks this goes to be the best wide-perspective lens in your equipment and I unquestionably suggest all 3 of Tamron’s mirrorless lenses collectively with the 28-75 f/2.8 and the 70-180 f/2.8. They’re very lightweight, present massive pictures, and likewise you might properly per likelihood disclose the precise similar filters on all 3 of them. Tamron REALLY assign their pondering caps on with this line and preserve delivered a big line up of lenses. This family of lenses is sort of a cheat code for anyone appropriate beginning out. Should you’re getting a mirrorless physique, provoke with the 28-75 f/2.8 and lag from there, you might properly per likelihood additionally not be upset and these will abet you for years.

The sharpness prepare is not unquestionably a agonize everytime you happen to dangle in thoughts the vogue just about all folks interacts with photos now, the largest show camouflage they’re going to look it on is an iPad. The smaller you rating your photograph the additional crimes you might properly per likelihood veil.

2. Should you print one factor else greater than a typical sheet of printer paper, or raise out editorial work I raise out not think about the Tamron will defend up. I preserve 8×12 prints from every and every lenses and I’ll provoke to look the prepare descend off on the edges, nonetheless I’m additionally seeking out for it. Should you would like the cleanest, clearest, crispiest picture edge to edge for these massive beautiful are prints, billboards, posters, and so on. Connect in thoughts the Sigma. It’s heavy which makes it unquestionably really feel immense strong everytime you happen to’re hand-conserving photos. Going through the bulbous entrance prepare will stress you loopy, specifically everytime you happen to slap a $400 filter equipment on there to keep up a polarizer. Nonetheless the problems this lens can raise out blow me away day-to-day. This may focal stage really as much as 7 inches a good distance from the entrance prepare. You might maybe properly per likelihood cram this lens anyplace and rating some unquestionably weird photos. This lens for me speaks to the professional switching platforms or any individual that could be a dazzling artwork work/ massive construction level out photographer.

Within the sphere comparability

Talents these extra comparability pictures from each lens the place I’m going shot for shot with each at a superb waterfall in West Virginia. The Sigma is on the head and the Tamron is on the bottom. Each of these have been shot at f/16, ISO 100, and a 2-second publicity.


Referring to the writer: Brad Denny is the photographer within the attend of the Restless and Wandering high-tail images weblog. The opinions expressed on this text are totally these of the writer. You might maybe properly per likelihood additionally purchase further of Denny’s work on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. This text grow to be additionally printed here.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

six + 10 =